If you are a die-hard Broadway lover, you would want to have Seth Rudetsky’s life. He hosts a Sirius XM show where he plays music from Broadway shows and talks to the biggest and brightest stars of the Great White Way. He writes a regular column for Playbill’s website. He tours the country combining Q&A’s with Broadway stars with performances in which he plays piano for them. (He has two scheduled for the Wallis Annenberg in the spring.)
In other words, Seth Rudetsky lives and breathes Broadway. So if you want to know the inside stories about all the famous folk who have spent time treading the boards in New York, Rudetsky’s book, Seth’s Broadway Diary #3 is essential reading.
Talking to someone who regularly interviews people himself is an interesting challenge. Since we spoke on the day of the Grammy nominations, we got right into it.
In the category of Best Cast Album the Grammy’s only have three nominees: Dear Evan Hansen, Hello Dolly! and Come From Away. Did they miss something or is that a reflection of the past year of musical theatre?
Literally that to me is not the greater issue. The complete lack of caring about Broadway at the Grammy Awards is. Because they don’t give a shit. There’s no criterion? How can Hello Dolly! be up against Dear Evan Hansen? Are you comparing the scores? The recording? What are the Grammy Awards voting on? Where they have a thousand sub categories in other genres, they don’t have a best album of a show or best revival. It’s so insulting. It makes me angry.
When you tell these stories, whether in your columns or on your show, do the performers involved give you permission to do so? Or does it come with the territory when they tell you the stories?
Yes and no. I think I have a really good sense of what I can say and what I can’t. Last night after the concert [a series he produces called Concert For America: Stand Up, Sing Out! that raises funds for civil rights organizations] someone was telling me a story “not as a friend and not as a columnist.” I maybe have gotten someone annoyed at me three times. Do they realize it would go into my columns? Who cares? The stories are hilarious. If you don’t like it, don’t tell me anything. I’m not Pollyanna and I don’t want to write only positive stuff, but I won’t write mean-spirited stories.
Of all the relationships you’ve developed over the years, which one surprises you the most that it actually exists?
Probably Andrea Martin – because she’s such a close friend of mine. I was so obsessed with her growing up. It’s just weird how close we are and what a fan I was with the TV star. Almost every idol I’ve met has been exactly what I wanted them to be. She’s hilarious. Just the other day it was really weird talking to Andrea McArdle. I remember reading that Annie book with the red cover. She was a photograph on an album. I had never seen her live, but she was such a megastar. It’s nice that everyone has lived up to who I wanted them to be.
Do you think the price structure for Broadway shows will make it impossible for a future Seth Rudetsky’s to get exposure to shows the way you did?
I’m not an expert, but it began with the Broadway Inner Circle with The Producers. That was the first crazy megahit, more than Rent, where scalpers were making a lot of money and this scheme came up to bust scalpers. I was just thinking the other day it’s so expensive to put on a show. Most of those costs are initial costs. I wonder if there is a new tactic. Why can’t you borrow money on the run of the show? For every three months you run, you pay back what it would have cost.
If you’re going to talk about the next young Seth Rudetsky, the problem is the devastating destruction of arts in the schools. There has been such a marginalization of Broadway as something gay. The arts are considered gay and feminine and it can be cut because of misogyny. The arts were not feminine in the old days. Ed Sullivan was right wing, ultra-straight and he had Broadway on every week. Now if you like Broadway you are gay. How does a kid know they like to sing or act if they don’t have a chance to do it? That’s really where the fault is in finding our next Stephen Sondheim.
You did your own jukebox musical, Disaster! A Musical. But are you concerned that shows based on pre-existing material or jukebox musicals show a lack of imagination on producer’s parts?
Yes and no. People say, “Oh Seth, you took the lazy way out. You wrote a jukebox musical about disaster movies.” I did it because I really wanted to. I love disaster movies and 70s music. I think there’s this theory if you have a well-know title, that’s a surefire way to have a Broadway show. It isn’t. But it is a surefire way to get investors. It’s not a way to sell tickets.
I was talking to Hal Prince [director of Phantom of the Opera, Sweeney Todd and more] about when someone came to him with an idea. He said, “Nobody did that. We would talk and create it together. It used to be much more artistic.” There are still some producers that still do that. We don’t have a lot of them like we used to.
If you could go back in time and see any productions you never got a chance to see and performers you never got a chance to experience, what and who would they be?
100% Funny Girl with Barbra Streisand and West Side Story with Chita Rivera. I would die to see what Barbra sounded like live and would have died to see Chita do the original choreography for “America.” I think about it all the time. Those two 100%. [For the record, it took Seth about 2 seconds to start his answer to that question.]
You produced the Broadway for Orlando project after the massacre at the Pulse nightclub in Florida. And you have the Concert for America series. What’s the next phase of advocacy you have planned?
We are going to start in January doing salons. We did one in Judy Kuhn’s apartment [She starred in Fun Home, Les Misérables]. These are for causes or particular candidates we believe in. We’ve raised so much money. If anyone is reading this and wants to help a particular candidate or cause, keep us in mind.